News and Analysis of India
 

Sydney |3 years ago
East Timor courts 'failed state' tag
Thursday, 01 June 2006 | http://www.nerve.in/news:2535003282 | channel: Australasia

"The decision to have Portuguese as the national language has seen the education system reverse the gains made when Jakarta was in charge."
 
Sydney, June 1 (DPA) East Timorese too young to recall the dreadful violence that brought foreign troops rushing to the half-island in 1999 have been witnesses to a chilling flashback.

Armed gangs loot and burn, people flee their homes and take to the hills, ancient animosities between ethnic groups are settled in back alleys with swords and clubs, mobs ransack warehouses of aid agencies and fight over the spoils.

This time Indonesia cannot be blamed for a descent into anarchy that has cost dozens of lives, left thousands homeless and again trashed Dili, the picturesque seaside capital. The Indonesians, who invaded in 1975 and ruled with an iron fist for a quarter century, left seven years ago.

The East Timorese have had their own elected government since 2001 and have been formally independent since 2002. The blame for recent disgraceful scenes lies with the East Timorese themselves.

This round of violence began in May after 600 soldiers dismissed from the army by Prime Minister Alkatiri's government made common cause with others unhappy with his leadership.

Demonstrations degenerated into riots that pitted soldiers against police, those from the east of the country against those from the west, and supporters of Alkatiri against those seeking his removal.

Discipline within the security apparatus broke down. With law and order gone, mob rule took over. Alkatiri, under pressure from President Xanana Gusmao, called in Australian, Malaysian, New Zealand and Portuguese troops to separate the warring parties and restore order.

'The government has failed miserably,' Foreign Minister Jose Ramos Horta admitted.

'We have failed to embrace people who disagree with the government, we have not succeeded in addressing the problems in the military even though we knew about them,' Horta said.

East Timor's political problems are tricky. The dominant party is Fretilin, which holds 55 of the 88 seats in parliament. In May, with the active support of Ramos Horta, Alkatiri was re-elected leader in advance of a general election in May next year.

The popular Ramos Horta now wants the unpopular Alkatiri to resign. So does Mandela-like war hero Gusmao. But Alkatiri refuses and is pushing for some face-saving cabinet reshuffle to smooth over the cracks.

Australia, which led the international force that curbed Indonesia's goodbye-gift pillage in 1999, is desperate to stay out of local politics.

'We'll be encouraging them to run their own show again,' Australian Prime Minister John Howard said. 'We'll be giving them help, we'll be giving them advice, but in the end, if it is to be an independent country, East Timor has got to run itself.'

Howard is keenly aware that the million people that inhabit the region's poorest country have come to expect Australians to save them from themselves. Interventions are expensive, counter-productive and most worryingly, are an irritant to Australia's all-important relations with Indonesia.

The Australian National University's Andrew MacIntyre is adamant that Australia should leave nation building to the East Timorese and not allow the nascent country to become a client state.

'We cannot be the long-term providers of law and order,' MacIntyre said. 'We cannot broker durable political solutions to internal leadership struggles. We cannot drop in new systems of government. And we cannot drive job creation.'

Paul Cleary, who worked as a World Bank-funded adviser to Alkatiri, is also insistent that East Timor's politicians are the authors of the discord and should be left to fix the problems they have created.

'East Timor's unrest is the result of dissatisfaction by a widely unemployed population with a government seen as foreign, culturally insensitive, centralised and to some extent autocratic,' Cleary said.

'The trigger that transformed this dissatisfaction into violence was an inept administrative decision to sack almost 600 soldiers,' said Cleary.

The incompetence of the East Timor government is stark. Revenue from oil and gas fields shared with Australia has started rolling in. The government budget is higher than what is was when Indonesia ran the place. Yet there is little to show for government spending.

East Timor has the world's highest population growth rate. However, over half its workforce is unemployed.

The decision to have Portuguese as the national language has seen the education system reverse the gains made when Jakarta was in charge.

The scourge of corruption, something that East Timorese claimed would be gone with the Indonesians, is still deeply rooted.

PERMALINK

http://www.nerve.in/news:2535003282
You can quote the permanent link above for a direct link to the story. We do not archive or expire our news stories.

STORY OPTIONS
  Email this story to a friend
  XML feed for Australasia
SYDNEY Nerve
 Warne denies he had hot words with Ponting over IPL - 10 hours ago
 Brett Lee retires from Test cricket - 1 day ago
 Queensland parliament to serve Indian menu - 1 day ago
 Australian participation in IPL uncertain, says Official - 2 days ago
 Lost desert ants use distance walked to find way back home - 3 days ago
 Oat extract likely to boost brain power - 3 days ago
 Alcohol tends to blur race recognition - 3 days ago
 Australia satisfied with security, will participate in World Cup - 4 days ago
 'No credible threat' so Australian hockey team to play in Delhi - 4 days ago
 Delhi Police 'rubbish' Tennis Australia's claim of stolen CWG plans - 5 days ago
 See all latest headlines from Sydney
RELATED NEWS
 Al Qeda linked Iran's rebel group selects new leader - 39 minutes ago
 EU welcomes India, Pakistan talks - 1 hour ago
 21 killed in fire at Bangladesh garment factory - 2 hours ago
 six killed in Peru plane crash - 3 hours ago
 Russia may free 45,000 prisoners of second world war - 4 hours ago
 Leona Lewis to create ethical clothing line - 5 hours ago
 Jeff Bridges hunting for final good role - 5 hours ago
 Matt Damon to play Senator Kennedy in new movie? - 5 hours ago
 Gaga teams up with Armani for world tour - 5 hours ago
 Akon quits new radio job - 5 hours ago
 See all latest headlines
LATEST TAGS
· Baz Luhrmann
· Chamma
· Protected Rainforest
· Indian Sugar Firm
· Indian Movie
· Nick Carter
· Shangu Patel
· Indian Association
· Mabira
· Mabira Rain Forest
· Scoul
· Sugar Corporation Of
· Mehta Group
· Mulago Hospital
· Translink
· Ugandan Indian Assoc
· Rajni Taylor
· Ugandan Government
· President Yoweri Mus
· Sugar Firm
· Nri Nightmare
· Indian Entrepreneur
· Racial Discriminatio
· Ruhakana Rugunda
· John Brumby
· Desi Dhaba
· Vindaloo Against Vio
· Vindaloo Against Vio
· Queensland Parliamen
· Racial Violence
· Crisis Management Gr
· Devang Rawal
· Sexual Health
· Asian Family
· Khulna District
· Power Plant
· Cardiac Surgeon
· Jedimetla
· Malla Reddy Group Of
· Narayana Hrudayalaya
· Largest Heart Hospit
· Narayana Hrudayalaya
· Healthcare Group
· Mathew Samuel
· Kalarickal
· Nataranan
· Mayilvahanan
· Mayilvahanan Nataran
· Palanisamy
· Sathyamurthy
· Mathew Samuel Kalari
· Girinath
· Maldives Government
· Memorandum Of Unders
· Top Hospital Chain
· Largest Healthcare G
· Apollo Family
· Apollo Hospital Fami
· Second Highest Civil
· Preetha Reddy
· Heart Institute
· Shroff Eye Clinic
· Noshir Shroff
· Indian Red Cross Soc
· Knee Surgery
· Chitranjan Singh Ran
· Asian Heart Institut
· Ramakant Panda
· Prathap Reddy
· Padma Award
· Laxmi Chand Gupta
· Dr Laxmi Chand Gupta
· Nirmal Kumar Ganguly
· Sixteen Doctors
· Singer Shilpa Rao
· Shilpa Rao
· Kala Ghoda Arts Fest
· Kya Mujhe Pyaar Hai
· Jaadu Hai Nasha Hai
· Spy Thriller
 
COPYRIGHTS INFORMATION
All rights reserved for news content. Reproduction, storage or redistribution of Nerve content and articles in any medium is strictly prohibited.
Contact Nerve Staff for any feedback, corrections and omissions in news stories.
 
Statewise News
Andhra Pradesh Nerve - Arunachal Pradesh Nerve - Assam Nerve - Bihar Nerve - Chandigarh Nerve - Chhattisgarh Nerve - Delhi Nerve - Goa Nerve - Gujarat Nerve - Haryana Nerve - Himachal Pradesh Nerve - Jammu and Kashmir Nerve - Jharkhand Nerve - Karnataka Nerve - Kerala Nerve - Lakshadweep Nerve - Madhya Pradesh Nerve - Maharashtra Nerve - Manipur Nerve - Meghalaya Nerve - Mizoram Nerve - Nagaland Nerve - Orissa Nerve - Pondicherry Nerve - Punjab Nerve - Rajasthan Nerve - Sikkim Nerve - Tamil Nadu Nerve - Tripura Nerve - Uttaranchal Nerve - Uttar Pradesh Nerve - West Bengal Nerve